Since I discovered the fault in my first Kryptonite New York Diamond lock, many people have contacted me to ask how they can tell if their lock is defective or not.
I’ve read comments suggesting that the extent to which the thin layer of textured, sparkly (anti grinder) material extends beyond the rubber cover of the shackle is a good indication of whether the lock is defective, or not.

Left: lots of anti grinder material. Right: no visible anti grinder material
Or that a big gap between the shackle and the crossbar indicates a faulty lock.

Left: big gap. Right: small gap
And a lot of people seem to be returning their locks based on these assessments.
So, I thought I would create a post where we can share our findings and hopefully dispel some of the misinformation (because I’m pretty sure many people are returning locks that are completely fine).
Below, I have provided better photos of the defective lock. Plus some photos of other locks that I have tested since (and were fine). And also photos of a load of new locks I have bought, to see if we can identify another defective lock based on certain characteristics.
Spoiler: I am publishing this post before I've tested all of the newest locks (just so people can see some of the photos), but I suspect that they will all pass the tests and that Kryptonite has indeed fixed the problem.
First, a timeline recap:
- April 2025 I bought a lock from a European website which was very easily cut at the base of the shackle
- May 2025 Kryptonite contacted me and I sent the faulty lock back to them
- May 2025 Kryptonite sent me 2 replacement locks. I tested one and the fault was fixed
- September 2025 I bought another lock from a European website. I tested it, and again the fault was fixed
- September 2025 a French video was published, which seemed to show the same fault
- January 2026 I bought 3 locks from Amazon and 1 lock from an independent shop to test again.
Now, a summary table of my tests so far:
Lock | Time to cut base side 1 | Time to cut base side 2 |
|---|---|---|
1. Faulty lock | 13 sec | x |
2. Lock Kryptonite sent | 6:10 min | x |
3. Lock from independent shop | I gave up after 3 discs! | I gave up after 2 discs! |
3. Lock Kryptonite sent | 5:05 min | 5:05 min |
4. Lock from Amazon | 10:20 min | 5:25 min |
5. Lock from independent shop | ? | ? |
6. Lock from Amazon | ? | ? |
7. Lock from Amazon | ? | ? |
There is obviously a massive variation in the times and the number discs needed to cut through the base of the shackles. But apart from the first lock in the table, they are no worse (and usually much better) than the other angle grinder resistant bike locks I've tested.
Certainly the only lock I would say is faulty is the first one.
Here are the photos so far (you can click on the photos to see higher resolution versions)...
Locks I have Tested
1. The Faulty Lock
The faulty New York Diamond looked great when locked up. The shackle had a very tight fit into the crossbar with no gap at all:

Faulty lock: the shackle and crossbar have a very tight fit
However, you can see in the image below that there doesn't seem to be any textured, sparkly material (which is the anti grinder layer), extending beyond the shackle cover:

Faulty lock: no visible textured / sparkly material at all
There does seem to be a third layer of material, but it seems like it's just the covering, with no texture, indicating that the actual anti grinder material which should be underneath, is absent.

Faulty lock: three layers of cover, but no visible texture / sparkle on third layer
Below is the crossbar of the faulty lock after the shackle was cut. Note the cut is straight across. I didn't need to cut downwards into the shackle.

Faulty lock: cut straight across the shackle
In the next photo of the shackle, you can see that the cut is after the anti angle grinder material (which is textured and sparkly) ends. Note also how high up the shackle I cut: it's nowhere near the tip.

Faulty lock: textured / sparkly material ends before the cut
I was able to cut the faulty lock at the base of the shackle with just 1 disc in just 13 seconds, with the disc completely unaffected at the end.
Kryptonite contacted me to say that the faulty lock was part of a bad batch and sent me two new locks to test.
2. The first lock that Kryptonite sent me
The first lock from Kryptonite performed really well. I needed 25 discs and over 6 minutes of active cutting to get through the base of the shackle!

Good lock: plenty of textured / sparkly material visible
Look how high I was forced to cut the shackle. Again, I was nowhere near the tip. So there was plenty of anti grinder material to spare.
In the photo below, you can see the edges of the sparkly layer of anti grinder material in the crossbar. This stops you cutting too far diagonally down into the shackle at the crossbar.

Good lock: you can see the diamond material around the edge of the opening
This lock was obviously protected just as well at the base as it was further up the shackle (where I needed 13 discs and 3 minutes 11 seconds of cutting to cut it).
3. The second lock I bought
I was aware that Kryptonite should have hand-picked the best locks for me to test, so I bought another lock to test again.

Good lock crossbar
Again you can see how the anti grinder material extended the whole length of the shackle (that I was able to attack).

Good lock: again plenty of sparkly material extending beyond the cover
Once I had established that it was well protected at the base, I stopped cutting: it was clear that I would need to waste a load of discs to get through either side.

This lock was clearly well protected at the base of the shackle
4. The second lock Kryptonite sent me
Once I'd finished testing the first lock that Kryptonite sent me, I didn't bother with the second one, as I presumed it would perform equally well.

Same times but with different types of discs
However, bizarrely, the second lock, looks the most defective out of all the locks I have seen so far!
There is massive gap between the shackle and the crossbar:

This is the biggest gap I have seen between shackle and crossbar
And there appears to be very little anti grinder material at the ends of the shackle. However, I think I can see some on the left-hand side. And I suspect there is plenty underneath the cover.

Not much material on the right but there seems to be some on the left
It seems very unlikely that Kryptonite would make the mistake of sending me a faulty one, but I tested it to make sure.
And by attacking the gap between the shackle and the crossbar, I was able to cut it faster than the previous two locks.

I cut the left with a diamond disc. I cut the right with regular discs
I took me 3 discs and over 5 minutes to cut through the side with the big gap. I cut the other side with a diamond disc as part of another test, but it took me exactly the same amount of time.

