Kryptonite New York Diamond Review: From Zero to Hero?

Kryptonite New York Diamond Review: From Zero to Hero?

Last Updated on June 24, 2026 | 13 Comments

I have now tested 6 Kryptonite New York Diamond bike locks and have another 2 waiting to be tested!

Why so many?

Well, the first one that I bought had a fault that allowed me to cut through the base of the shackle using only 1 angle grinder disc in just 13 seconds.

And despite Kryptonite replacing the faulty lock with two non-faulty locks, me buying another one myself, and all three performing exceptionally well in subsequent tests, people continue to message me (and post on Reddit, etc.) with concerns about faulty New York Diamond locks.

Kryptonite New York Diamond with abrasive disc

All the subsequent locks have performed really well

Which is understandable: it’s a very expensive lock, the flaw was very serious, and Kryptonite has not provided any public information about the situation. People are rightly concerned about unwittingly spending a lot of money on a lock that’s not fit for purpose.

Rumors swirl about what indicates a faulty lock. That it’s the size of the gap between the shackle and crossbar. Or how far the anti-angle grinder material extends down the tip of the shackle. And people are returning lots of locks on this basis.

Loads of people are messaging me about this. If you are worried that you might have a faulty Kryptonite New York Diamond, I have written an in depth guide that I hope helps!

So I bought several more locks to test, document my findings, and hopefully come to some solid conclusions.

I haven’t tested them all yet. But from the six locks I have tested, I feel pretty confident in saying the following:

  • The first lock was the only faulty lock I have tested
  • A big gap between the shackle and the crossbar does not indicate a faulty lock
  • The anti-grinder material not extending very far down the tip of the shackle does not indicate a faulty lock
  • The only indication of a faulty lock is if there is no anti-grinder material at all at the bottom of the shackle
  • Even non-faulty locks remain vulnerable at the base of the shackle

The Kryptonite New York Diamond is definitely weaker at the base of the shackle (more on this below). But a lot of the anti-angle grinder bike locks are weaker at this point. And although the weakness is serious, it's not easy to exploit. 

I will, of course, update my reviews as I continue the testing. But as it stands at the moment, I think the fault has been fixed, and the Kryptonite New York Diamond is one of the most angle grinder-resistant bike locks I have tested yet.

But let’s get into this in more detail…

Competitively priced, inconsistent build quality. Unrivaled angle grinder resistance at the top but vulnerable at the bottom of the shackle.

Summary

Kryptonite New York Diamond

Kryptonite New York Diamond

My score:

Rating: 4 stars

Check price:

Shackle thickness:

16 mm

Weight:

5.07 lb (2.3 kg)

Size (internal):

3.75 x 8"
(9.5 x 20.4 cm)

Other Security Ratings:

Sold Secure Motorcycle Diamond and Bicycle Diamond

Kryptonite New York Diamond Pros

  • Exceptional angle grinder resistance,
  • Competitively priced